Declining Acceptance of Nearly All Anti-Jewish Stereotypes
There has been a decline in the level of acceptance of nearly all anti-Jewish stereotypes since 1992.
The previous anti-Semitism studies showed that acceptance of classic ethical
stereotypes traditionally attributed to Jews had steadily declined from 1964 to 1992, but
that this decline was accompanied by a rise in acceptance of the notion that Jews had too
much power in the U.S. The 1998 survey finds a fall-off in acceptance of both strains of
anti-Jewish sentiment.
The biggest drop since 1992 has come on statements about the perceived level of power
Jews have in American society:
|
Drop in % of Americans agreeing w/ statement from 1992 to 1998 |
| Jews
have too much power in the U.S. today.* |
-20 |
| Jews
have too much control and influence on Wall Street. |
-11 |
| Jews
have too much power in the business world. |
-8 |
| (*question wording slightly different in 1998 than past studies) |
These declines have been accompanied by further drops in the percentage of Americans
accepting some of the more classic negative stereotypes about Jewish business practices:
|
Drop in % of Americans agreeing w/ statement from 1992 to 1998 |
| Jews
are more willing to use shady practices to get what they want |
-8 |
| Jews
are [not] as honest as other businessmen |
-6 |
| Jewish
businessmen are so shrewd that other people do not have a fair chance at competition |
-5 |
The proportion of Americans agreeing with nearly every other anti-Jewish statement
tested is also down from 1992:
|
Drop in % of Americans agreeing w/ statement from 1992 to 1998 |
| Jewish
employers go out of their way to hire other Jews.* |
-13 |
| Jews have
a lot of irritating faults.. |
-8 |
| Jews
still talk too much about what happened to them in the Holocaust.* |
-8 |
| Jews
don't care what happens to anyone but their own kind. |
-7 |
| Jews
always like to be at the head of things. |
-6 |
| Jews have
too much influence over the American news media.* |
-5 |
| Jews are
more loyal to Israel than to America. |
-3 |
| Jews
stick together more than other Americans. |
+6 |
| (*denotes questions not in the 11-question index) |
The one question on which the level of acceptance has increased from 1992 to 1998 is
that Jews "stick together" more than other Americans. This is clearly among the
least offensive of the various anti-Jewish attributes tested and, as the 1992 study
pointed out, is not always considered to be a negative characteristic. Among certain
segments of the population, "sticking together" is considered to be a positive
attribute.
Influence Over
Hollywood and the News Media
Several questions in the survey addressed public perceptions about the level of Jewish
influence or control over Hollywood and the news media. The proportion of Americans who
believe that Jews "have too much influence over the American news media" is down
to 12% in 1998, from 17% in 1992. At the same time, there has been a slight increase, to
24% from 21%, in the percentage of Americans who feel that "the movie and television
industries are pretty much run by Jewish executives."
Other results in the survey indicate that much of the public is critical of the role TV
and movie executives are playing in American society. A solid majority (63%) agrees with
the notion that "the people who run the TV networks and the major movie studios do
not share the moral and religious beliefs of most Americans."
But the public overwhelmingly rejects the idea
that the programming decisions of network executives are influenced by the fact that they
might be Jewish. Fewer than one-in-ten (9%) Americans believe that "network
executives who are Jewish tend to allow more sex and violence programming than non-Jewish
executives."
A similar question about the perceived lack of more "Christian-oriented"
television programs provokes essentially the same response. Fewer than one-in-ten (9%)
Americans feel that "the executives of the three major [TV] networks may be blocking
Christian-oriented programming because they are Jewish."
Positive Images of Jews
While this study, like the past ones, is focused primarily on the level of acceptance
of negative stereotypes, it is important to note that a majority of Americans accept each
of the positive statements about Jews which was presented in the survey.
In fact, as was seen in past studies, positive images of Jews are so prevalent that a
majority of even the most anti-Semitic Americans accept four of the five positive
statements which were included in the 1998 survey.
This has been a consistent finding since the 1964 study, and is not as contradictory as
it may seem at first glance. As the Tenacity of Prejudice, a book based on the
1964 survey, points out: "It is in the nature of prejudice that positive beliefs
coexist with negative ones."
Overall, more than four-in-five Americans believe that Jews are "just as honest as
other businessmen" (85%); that they "have a strong faith in God" (83%); and
that they are "warm and friendly people" (82%). A majority of Americans also
believe that Jews "have contributed much to the cultural life of America" (73%)
and that "because of theirhistory, Jews have a special commitment to social justice
and civil rights" (61%).
Among the most anti-Semitic group of Americans, 75% believe that Jews have a strong
faith in God; 64% believe they have contributed much to the cultural life of America; 61%
believe Jews are warm and friendly; and 61% believe they have a special commitment to
social justice. As previous surveys have shown, only on the issue of honesty does this
majority fall away; 49% of the most anti-Semitic Americans say they Jews are just as
honest as other businessmen, while 46% way they are not as honest.
Next: Which Americans are Most Likely to Hold Anti-Semitic Views?
|