One of the most notable anti-Semitic movements to develop over the past two decades has
been an organized effort to deny the established history of Nazi Germany's extermination
of six million Jews during the Holocaust. In the United States the movement has been
known in recent years primarily through the publication of advertisements in college
campus newspapers. The first of these ads claimed to call for "open debate on the
Holocaust." While discussion of historical events is certainly useful and
educational, "debating" the Holocaust would be like debating whether American
colonists even, in fact, fought for independence from England in 1776. Another
ad questioned the authenticity of the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington,
D.C. These ads have been published in several dozen student newspapers on campuses across
the country.
Similar examples of such propaganda have begun to appear
on the Internet as well. In addition to creating their own home pages, Holocaust
deniers have sometimes crashed the sites of legitimate Holocaust and Jewish discussion
groups in an effort to spread false information and harass Jews. In addition, Holocaust
deniers have advertised their Web sites in classified ads in college and community
newspapers.
These paid advertisements and Internet activities have
appeared continuously since 1991. Though there is no evidence that they have persuaded
large numbers of students to doubt the settled record of events which make up the
Holocaust, the ads have sparked controversy between Jewish and non-Jewish students. In
fact, this is exactly the goal of the Holocaust deniers.
By attacking the facts of the Holocaust and maintaining
that their attack is merely an unorthodox point of view, Holocaust deniers demonstrate
their subtle but hateful anti-Semitic beliefs. They try to spread the view that Jews are
only using the Holocaust to take advantage of non-Jewish guilt and that Jews control the
media and academic world. Some of these beliefs, in fact, are similar to those which
helped bring Hitler to power in Germany during the 1930s.
The roots of Holocaust denial - or Holocaust
"revisionism," as its adherents refer to the movement - can be found in the
language of the Nazis itself, which tried to hide acts of imprisonment, slave labor,
and mass murder under euphemisms such as"relocation" and "The Final
Solution." After World War II, former Nazis and their supporters similarly claimed
that Hitler's hatred of the Jews had been misinterpreted, and that the numerous
confessions of Nazi leaders describing the genocide had been coerced by the Allies. This
neo-Nazi movement also dismissed the testimony of survivors from the concentration camps
as exaggeration and lies. Other political extremists in the 1960s and 1970s, such as
radical anti-Israel groups or fringe conspiracy theorists, echoed the views of these
right-wing anti-Semites.
As an organized movement, Holocaust denial began in 1979
with the founding of a group called the Institute for Historical Review (IHR). The IHR
publishes a magazine (the Journal of Historical Review), holds conferences, and
distributes a variety of anti-Jewish books - all devoted to the idea that Hitler's record
of atrocities is a fraud concocted by a powerful, secret conspiracy of Jews. Among those
connected to the IHR is Bradley Smith, the man responsible for most of the Holocaust
denial advertisements in college newspapers.
Many proponents of Holocaust denial claim that their propaganda has been misrepresented, and that they are victims of
yet another conspiracy, also led by Jews, to suppress independent research. In making
these claims, Holocaust deniers try to exploit the sympathy of most people, especially
students, for academic debate and honest critical thinking. These arguments are dishonest,
though, for three main reasons:
(1) Holocaust deniers reject all evidence and research that contradicts
their views. Rather than promote honest research, these propagandists wish to challenge the historical record with their
own views, which have no credibility.
(2) The "research" the deniers use comes to conclusions that
are false. Among the untruths
routinely promoted are the claims that no gas chambers existed at Auschwitz, that only
600,000 Jews were killed rather than six million, and that Hitler had no murderous
intentions toward Jews or other groups persecuted by his government.
(3) Holocaust deniers conceal the true motivation for their propaganda. Though the deniers often try to assume a scholarly,
reasonable tone in their public statements, in their more private newsletters,
conferences, and e-mails they typically display hatred of Jews, admiration for Nazism, and
contempt for free speech and democracy.